After agreeing on posing as Pacey's sister at a party, Joey demands to be taken home. Pacey makes a quick stop at a local K-Mart to buy some preservatives for later that night, and they accidentally get locked inside the supermarket. They're forced to spend the night there and talk about their friendship and relationship, past and future, which eventually leads to a kiss. Pacey and Joey sleep on each other's arms and are awaken by a store employee. As they leave the store they wonder how this night locked at K-Mart will affect their relationship.